The Robert Quinn Non-Controversy
DE C.J. Ah You is out this week with a wrist injury, which means first-round pick Robert Quinn will more than likely be in action this week. Quinn was (in)famously left inactive last week, causing a bit of outrage among fans. I mostly avoided the subject on the front page of the site, as you may have noticed, because I felt like it was a non-controversy, something best left to talk radio and message boards.
Quinn played no football in 2010 because of the NCAA's exploitative rules and restrictions on the very athletes from which they profit. The lockout scuttled what little time players get in the spring to practice, a particularly costly thing for the rookies.
Though we don't know exactly what Spagnuolo was thinking, your mind does not have to reach very into the imagination to assume that Quinn, after so much time away from football, was simply not ready to play. Occam's Razor makes for bad ratings though and a mini-storm brewed, even after Spagnuolo explained his decision with a pretty straight forward answer...that Quinn wasn't ready enough to use a roster spot at the expense of other needs.
And what if it was something more? Last year, Brandon Gibson and Bradley Fletcher both found themselves out of action and in Spagnuolo's doghouse. Gibson was there to start the season, inactive the first two games because of Spagnuolo's dissatisfaction with his practice habits. Fletcher was never left out of uniform, but he did famously not get the start against San Francisco the first time the Rams played them last year, an overtime loss. Reportedly, Kevin Dockery's start over Fletcher that week had something to do with practice habits as well. Fletcher got into the game after Dockery was burned on a 65-yard pass from Troy Smith to Josh Morgan.
There were a few unsubstantiated rumors that Quinn was perhaps getting some similar bad reviews from the coaches. Again, good grist for talk radio the message boards. Even if that was the case, a good coach would never use the press to send a message.
Last week's tempest in a teapot looks to have blown over now.
Today, Spagnuolo gave Quinn a good review for his work in practice this week, calling his play "impressive." The Rams' pass rush figures heavily into the game plan against the Giants this week, with a relatively inexperienced offensive line still getting used to working together.
21 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
If theres one thing even RamChop would've agreed to on here
It’s that Spags at the least knows more about developing athletic DE’s than us
by King Sam Rules! on Sep 16, 2011 3:21 PM CDT via mobile reply actions
It was a travesty to end all travesties!
Nay! That douth not exclaim my feelings of injustice enough! We must do’eth something!
or...
if you are talk radio and need to manufacture something out of nothing to justify your existence.
Future Redbirds! www.futureredbirds.net
Rams Gab! www.ramsgab.com
On a completely unrelated note
Does anyone feel like the guy behind Quinn is checking out his ass in the picture.
That is all.
good call rod,
i have to agree, how bout bajema? Any pics of em without the helmut? Hes got a forehead like a drive in movie theatre..
My two favorite teams, the St. Louis Rams and whoever's playing the winers.
by caliramsfan1 on Sep 16, 2011 4:55 PM CDT up reply actions
I was looking at the picture going... "Is he hiding a shoulder injury?" LOL!
- And here's the Rams' 2010 season in a series. Incomplete pass, 18-yard run, incomplete pass, 7-yard run, 5-yard pass, 3-yard run, sack, incomplete pass, punt. Shoot me. - 3K
non controversy
also known as, why I shouldn’t respond to STL radio “talent” on Twitter when they use tags like #bustalert after 1 game. Otherwise I get too fired up and have to give myself a “twitter timeout”.
Future Redbirds! www.futureredbirds.net
Rams Gab! www.ramsgab.com
I think I know the "Talent" of whom you speak
Is it the very same talent who’s live read claims that a health supplement has allowed him to reach the 4mile limit in 30 minutes?
I need to get me some of that!
by @EricFromSTL on Sep 16, 2011 4:12 PM CDT via iPhone app up reply actions
Honestly, I'm still bothered by it
If he was inactive this week (assuming Ah You was healthy), that I would understand, because against the Giants, we need guys getting to the QB. If he’s not ready for that because of 18 months with basically no football, I get that.
My issue is that against Philly, we needed ATHLETICISM and CONTAINMENT, both of which a guy like Quinn excels at. He would have a shot to catch Vick. He could push that tackle outside and corral Vick to the center.
I just felt like Quinn’s unique talents would have been a boon against Vick’s athleticism, and not dressing him was a mistake
I look at it as a severe miscalculation
I can understand the desire to have an extra DT but not at the expense of someone with Quinn’s explosiveness. We’d been better off not dressing the extra WR since he can’t catch anyway ; )
Personally I think they were trying to:
A) send Quinn a message to step up
B) protect him from having a hangover effect from having to chase down Vick. We certainly don’t wan’t him gun-shy in terms of his confidence of getting to the QB.
I guess I can partially understand the logic but I just don’t think we can afford to healthy scratch a first round pick.
I doubt you'll check this out again Van...
But did you mean “start” on the caption of the picture, or did you just mean dress? Because I doubt he starts over Hall
spags reasoning made sense,
and we aren’t seeing how he performs at practice, if hes getting his assignments and so forth. His raw skills will get him only so far, and the rust will wear off over time.
My two favorite teams, the St. Louis Rams and whoever's playing the winers.
Lets hope Quinn exceeds expectations!
- And here's the Rams' 2010 season in a series. Incomplete pass, 18-yard run, incomplete pass, 7-yard run, 5-yard pass, 3-yard run, sack, incomplete pass, punt. Shoot me. - 3K
really?
that would be awesome. some said he would have been maybe top 5 if he had played his last year. as is he was projected top 10 but who knew there would be so many qb’s going that early? i think the question on his health was a factor to some too but his upside is said to be stellar.
aaaaaaaaaaaaand I'm working
FIRE EVERYONE
by Notorious PSC on Sep 16, 2011 8:40 PM CDT up reply actions
too much is being thought about this. It’s simple.. were just used to having no depth whatsoever that, our 1st nd 2nd’s even 3rd rounders get into the starting lineup right away.. see our last 3 seasons.. anyway were fortunate to see our rookies player sooner rather than later. Just look at other teams that have established depth.. there rookies barely play, while we play all of ours.
what's worse is that the dude who does rosters for Madden
Donny Moore, removed him from the Rams depth chart assuming he was injured.
Can you believe that dude gets paid for that shit?
http://brotherspork.wordpress.com/

by 






























