Vick or Tebow

My vote is for Tebow in this one. Although it definitely wouldn’t hurt my feelings to see Vick out there for the Rams given our current QB problems, I think Tebow brings 2 things to the rams that Vick can’t. The first being that, if anything, he has room to improve( younger than vick) and could actually produce in the pros, which many people don’t believe will happen (even more of an incentive for him to produce) and the second being publicity if anything. With Suh coming to the rams first overall, which barring a terrible combine, should happen, and drafting Tebow in the later rounds of the draft if he’s there, two of the biggest holes we have would possibly be filled depending on how he turned out…and lets be honest, a risk on Tebow later in the draft (only if he’s in the later rounds!!!) would be better than seeing Vick out there and not having any young QB behind him in the Depth Chart.

First off, i’m not going to get into why we should not pick Vick.
Second off, I want to say I realize that what we have seen from Tebow throughout his college career is not what you would say qualifies him to be a great NFL quarterback. I know everyone says he won’t produce in the NFL, which may very well be true. BUT, there is one thing you can not bring into question when it comes to Tim Tebow. He is a winner. He is a true football player. He is a extremely high character guy who puts absolutely everything he possibly has on the line to win a game. When people doubt Tebow he steps up to the challenge and produces what he needs to produce for his team. Could it possibly be that since everyone is questioning him now, he will step up his game up and produce in ways that no one thinks he is capable of.
The system he played in didn’t allow him to show if he could function in a pro-style offense, so yeah, noone knows for sure if he can, but he is not a bad passer. His passing stats are, like this post says, are good.
Tebow is a young determined man who was one of the best college players in the history of college football. I, personally wouldnt mind spending a third round draft pick on the kid. What if he proves everyone wrong ? I realize this could be a long shot, and im not trying to be a huge tebow supporter but if he can help this team then id say go for him… not vick.

I get it what draft pundits say about Tebow, however he is coachable, determined, leader and has that “it” quality. He does need to work on his mechanics, but a good coach can correct that, but leadership is hard to come by. What I like the most about Tebow over Vick, is the unknown. You know what your going to get with Vick, but Tebow is an open canvas.

As of today ( alot can change up to draft day ) I wouldn’t draft him before the 4th.

Vick isn’t the future. If he wouldn’t have gone to prison- yes, we could go for him. But he’s had almost zero experience for a long time, and isn’t the type of accurate passer we need in a WC offense. He’s a “trick” guy. Roll him out and the teams won’t know what to do. I’m surprised his legs have lasted so long.

Tebow…meh. I like how everyone calls him a winner. There is no doubt he lead a great team, but I’m curious as to how hard it is to win at a massive college who has a massive football recruiting budget and constantly picks some of the best high school players out of the country to play for them. Tebow is a good player in a spread offense, but the fact of the matter is that he has no technical skills. He doesn’t throw right, he has bad mechanics. These are types of things that need to be changed, and who knows what the hell will happen when they are changed. He might not even be the same player.

I’m not saying we shouldn’t draft him, but There is no way someone should spend a 1st round pick on him. He simply needs to be coached too much to be drafted that high.

I saw Tebow week after week down here…much as I hate to say it dude is money at the college lvl. However I dont believe he translates to the NFL as a QB. I may be wrong but thats just my opinion. That being said I would take him a thousand times over before I would put vick in my beloved Blue and Gold. If for no other reason than the upside is SOOOOO much higher with Tebow. Vick sucks and always has. He has no moral center and would be gone in a year anyway…..why waste the time? Between the two Take Tebow

He may have issues outside the NFL, but I don’t think he was ever considered a huge clubhouse cancer. The guys had a history of winning in the NFL. Vick has a lot more to lose if he messes up than the Rams do.

The falcons were a team built around and dependent on Mike Vick, when they lost him they lost their most important player. The Rams would not have to give much for him, and at worst would lose their stopgap QB.

You can be disappointed that the Rams would sign a guy with a bad history (but remember we still have Leonard Little on the team and the world hasn’t ended), but I don’t see how Vick can ruin a franchise, and there isn’t much to ruin to begin with. We’ve hit rock bottom from a football perspective.

I think Vick has already paid a lot for his crime, and his punishment fit his crime. I’m ready to give him a chance. That being said from a football perspective there are better QBs available, we should aim higher but I’ll take him over Tebow.

Nor are we the only ones whom hate him
http://www.stltoday.com/blogzone/round-two/round-two/2010/01/should-the-rams-pursue-michael-vick/

First, I’m not sure I understand how you can compare the numbers Vick and Tebow put up in college and make any type of argument one way or another if the Rams should acquire either of these guys.

Vick’s college numbers (in regards to us signing him) are irrelevant. And if they’re being used to try and figure out Tebow’s success potential, that’s not fair either. They’re two completely different runners. That’d be like comparing Barry Sanders to Christian Okoye. Vick is (was?) a shifty, super fast runner. Tebow is a bulldozer. There’s no comparison.

Anyway, of the two, I prefer Vick because he comes much cheaper. I can see Tebow having a little success in the NFL, but I also see him getting hurt regularly. His style of play (and his ability to throw) doesn’t lend itself too well to longevity in the NFL and if I’m drafting a guy, I want to know that his style of play can either evolve (which I don’t think it can) or be relied upon for the length of the contract and then some (again, I don’t think it can).

So, I go with Vick.

Now, I do have to say (after reading andy’s comment above this one), if Tebow is available in the 4th round (which he won’t be), then I’d be much more inclined to draft him. But, I really don’t see him making it past the 2nd (and I still think he’ll be going in the 1st to Jacksonville which is the only place I would think drafting him in the 1st round is a good idea….and is has nothing to do with his ability to play football well).

the patroits have 3, 2nd round pick’s. & brady need’s sum new blood backup, he wont get to the third round.